October 22, 2023

Beatup of a China Threat to the Maldives


The Maldives is the long string of islands, north to south between the southern tip of India and the US/UK Diego Garcia base.
---

A reading of the article below and Indian accounts would suggest China is building a South China Sea (SCS) like militarized island in the Maldives.

But the imagery suggests otherwise. It mainly looks like Chinese economic interests, especially building Maldive tourist developments, are challenging Indian economic interests.

India assumes the Maldives are in its backyard.

MARCO GIANNANGELI for the UK Express reports Oct 21, 2023: 

"World warned China 'setting up new military base in Indian Ocean' in major power play

China could be set to develop a new military base in the Indian Ocean following elections in the Maldives, intelligence sources warned.

The move would further solidify Beijing’s influence in the Indian Ocean and place Chinese submarines closer to UK and US military assets in Chagos, Diego Garcia and the Seychelles, not to mention India itself.

It follows victory by China-leaning Mohamed Muizzu, who campaigned on a platform of “India out “ to beat incumbent President Ibrahim Mohamed Solih in general elections held a fortnight ago

The results mark a return of a pro-China stance held by the Maldives before Solih came to power in 2018.

They are also a blow to New Delhi which had come to regard the islands as part of its sphere of influence.

[For some reason the author has decided to add this totally unrelated issue] The news comes as the head MI5 warned China was trying to steal nuclear technology from the UK and attempt to scupper the crucial nuclear submarine deal struck between Britain, the US and Australia.

Muizzu has already publicly pledged to expel a force of around 75 Indian soldiers ostensibly based on the islands to maintain and operate two rescue helicopters and a maritime surveillance plane donated by New Delhi.

The rescue assets have been used to save 523 lives in more than 500 medical evacuations over the past five years.

While it is unlikely that ties with India will be completely severed, Muizzu will attempt to consolidate economic ties with Beijing.

While no mention has yet been made of allowing a Chinese military footprint, senior government and intelligence sources in the islands are concerned that China will use the excuse of protecting vital energy routes to call for it.

“We feel it is only a matter of time for Beijing to play this card, and we are not sure President Muizzu will be inclined to resist it,:” said one senior source in Maldives capital Male.

It is not the first time the threat of a Chinese military base has surfaced in the Maldives.

[Location of a Chinese tourist deveopment] In 2020 satellite images showed evidence of mass construction on the island of Feydhoo Finolhu, which had been leased by China until 2026 [or for 50 years until 2066  ] for $4m by pro-China president Abdulla Yameen four years previously,

[However there is an argument that tiny Feydhoo Finolhu is a Chinese investment Tourist Atoll - with the alleged growth mainly consisting of tourist huts on pontoons over water - see Youtube]

Significantly the island has also been expanded from 38,000 sq. metres to measure 100,000 sq meters in size [about the size of a shopping mall and carpark], in a move which echoed China’s actions on the Spratly Islands in the South China Sea.

Any Chinese military base would strengthen China’s ability to control maritime freedom of movement in the region and act as a buffer for Taiwan, placing China’s People’s Liberation Army and Navy forces with just 1,000 km of India’s mainland. The distance to Diego Garcia and Chagos is considerably shorter.

Analysts also warn that a Chinese military outpost could be used to dock nuclear submarines in the region or collect hydrological data to track sub-surface operations of India like deployment submarines.

“China’s military ambitions are not yet clear but, given Beijing’s interest in a bigger presence in the Indian Ocean, the prospect of a Chinese military base is a concerning one,’ said Shiza Abbassi, intelligence analyst for South Asia with the Sibylline strategic risk group.

“China has been seeking a way to increase its influence for quite a while.

“It has already established a heavy footprint in Pakistan and influence in Sri Lanka as part of the so-called ‘string of pearls’ effort to undermine India’s influence in South Asia.

She added: “A military base in the Maldives would chime with its broader vision. And because China’s energy supplies pass through the Maldives, it would make sense for Beijing to make the case that its military presence would simply ensure these supplies.

“President Muizzu has left the door very much open for this.”

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Pete

Thanks for this coverage. The parallels with Chinese strategy in the Solomon Islands are obvious.

The comments of French Anonymous on other recent threads reminded me of another article I saw recently on the proposed Australia - France - India Trilateral Cooperation Agreement in the Indian Ocean. If AUKUS is not approved in the US congress, Australia should seriously look at this as “Plan B”. This article suggests it was still of interest to India.
https://www.delhipolicygroup.org/publication/policy-briefs/reviving-india-france-australia-trilateral-cooperation-in-the-indian-ocean.html

Looking back, I have to wonder if it would not have been possible for the RAN to negotiate a three way SSN construction program with France and India in the same way as we have done with UK and USA under AUKUS? It might save a lot of time and money.

Pete said...

Hi Anonymous at 10/22/2023 11:59 PM

Two major problems with Australia going into an SSN deal with France and/or India, include:

1. Macron isn't interested - see https://www.france24.com/en/france/20221117-macron-says-france-s-submarine-cooperation-offer-with-australia-still-on-the-table

Macron "said France would not supply nuclear submarines to foreign countries, so the offer [to Australia] related only to conventional vessels."

and

2. Australia would not want to be associated, even indirectly, with India's main SSN partner, which as with the Arihant-class, will be Russia. 1,000s of Indian nuclear technicians and submariners have had long stays in Russia for nuclear training and research since the 1980s, to this day.
ie high chance of too many Indians persuaded to be Russian agents in the nuclear submarine and reactor research, sectors.

India, in terms of SSNs (reactors and all) would be intimately dealing with the 100s of Russian advisers in India and Russians working with 100s of Indians in Russia. One activity is planning and upgrading the second Akula SSN, possibly K-519 "Iribis", for long lease to India. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akula-class_submarine#Units

Russian built Iribis would both act as a training vessel for Indian crews (with some Russian advisers aboard) and much of its technonology would go into India's SSN known as Project 75 Alpha.

Regards Pete