October 30, 2026

Australian Submarine Agency in Denial, Aus Sub Future Bleak, US & UK Rooted

The Collins RAN submarine service crews are still suffering long term engine reliability problems and shallow diving depths.

Meanwhile big money is going to the political spin doctors of the Australian Submarine Agency (ASA). Pretty website :).

The future Collins Life of Type Extension (LOTE) will provides A$2+ Billion per submarine with deeper maintenance than usual and the regular, standard software upgrades (all misinformed as "BRAND NEW LOTE"). Note Australia's big project tradition to take twice as long at 3 times the price to do anything. No hoped for LOTE replacement of the last operating Australian only Garden Island-Hedemora submarine diesels with modern, upgradable MTU 4000s. In connection to not upgrading diesels, see effectively an ASA Brief that desperately hopes for RAN Virginias in the 2030s so the LOTE will make sense. The LOTE, at Osborne shipyard in South Australia, is all about buying votes with Federal Government 10s  $Billions in South Australia.

No LOTE replacement of Captain only view hull penetrating/hull weakening periscopes. No whole command team can view non-penetrating optronic masts. See another effectively ASA Brief on this.

Many Aussie $Billions are being thrown at AUKUS Incorporated, especially the:

-  US highly profitable GD-EB and HII.

The US is suffering from:
-  worsening labor shortages
-  slower builds of subs (especially future larger Virginia Block Vs)
-  at higher prices
-  crippling Virginia maintenance delays
-  all Los Angeles class SSNs will be retired by the mid 2030s even those with life extensions
-  emergency extension of existing Ohio SSBN usage years
-  connected with increasing pressure to speed the (years behind schedule) higher priority Columbia SSBN construction (instead of Virginia construction) now through to 2041.

All the above meaning a rapidly worsening SSN shortage for the USN. Commissioning rates count the most, not submarines "ordered" or "cut steel".

Virginias for the RAN are contingent on a massive IMPROVEMENT (turnaround) in Virginia construction rates. These rates are getting worse, not better.


and

UK (in worse shape than US by every measure (labour force shortages, slower build times, at higher prices, acute Astute/Vanguard maintenance delays mainly due to defective PWR2 submarine reactors).

Little Australia, risking its whole defence budget is failing to provide buoyancy
 to the AUKUS, US and UK submarine calamity.

14 comments:

Shawn C said...

Hey Pete,

I stumbled across an interesting video by Gibraltar public media regarding newly declassified information on the 2000 HMS Tireless incident, where she suffered a primary reactor coolant leak and was dockside for a year for repairs. The leak was traced to thermal fatigue cracks, and lead to a class wide inspection and remedial action.

https://youtu.be/yEDC2hWhwpg?is=nkBY7-CDOuKqbyDu

So while faster, ‘cheaper’ repairs could be carries out in the UK, the political implications of towing an SSN to the UK made “on-site repair” a politically necessary. Note that there were objections from Spain, and the UK allowed Spanish nuclear experts to inspect the boat.


Pete2 said...

Thanks Shawn at 10/30/2026 8:48 PM

https://youtu.be/yEDC2hWhwpg?is=nkBY7-CDOuKqbyDu is very enlightening. and see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HMS_Tireless_(S88)#Primary_coolant_leak

It shows Britain had problems with PWR1 coolant leaks, even preceding the PWR2, with PWR2s proving much more defective.

Even with HMS Tireless coolant leak costs, out of service time, international and national (UK) embarrassment, the problems are far more severe now with the frequently unplanned out of service 5 Astutes and 4 Vanguards that are afflicting the Royal Navy, UK tax payers and NATO/Western Alliance.

In the absence of even one serviceable Astute not only French SSNs are needed to "delouse" Vanguard SSBNs as these SSBNs sail from or to Faslane but US SSNs are being called upon to guard UK SSBNs too.

Cheers Pete

Shawn C said...

The RN now has three Vanguard class ‘sailing around’, note that HMS Victorious entered deep maintenance and refueling in 2025, after two years dockside.

https://www.navylookout.com/three-royal-navy-vanguard-class-submarines-at-sea-does-not-signal-change-in-nuclear-posture/

Pete2 said...

Thanks Shawn at 10/31/2026 4:09 PM

Three Vanguard SSBNs ‘sailing around’ and probably not needing to do almost 7 month patrols anymore is great news for RN personnel trying to repair their (PWR2 embuggered) family lives.

https://youtu.be/0FHEeG_uq5Y?si=4V8B_XFL4eR8zWGk

Cheers Pete

Anonymous said...

There have also been problems with shellfish:

"A nuclear submarine commander has told how he narrowly avoided disaster
when the vessel's air-conditioning system became clogged with shellfish,
causing searing temperatures on board."

See:

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2014/jun/04/nuclear-submarine-commander-recounts-how-disaster-was-narrowly-avoided

Anonymous said...

Thanks Pete. It seems evident that the RN has concluded that the PWR2 maintenance problem for the combined SSN / SSBN fleet is beyond the capacity of RN maintenance. Hence they have prioritised keeping the SSBNs at sea to maintain their nuclear deterrent. Astutes thus remain laid up in dock.Why else would they all be there? They have the same PWR2 and are a newer design.

This will limit the RN’s ability to train new SSN crew. The RN would appear to be in danger of losing its SSN ASW skills in future. Rebuilding them later may take many years.

Anonymous said...

From a sub construction viewpoint it is worth understanding why the UK and USN are both unable to build SSNs fast enough. BAE in Barrow and GDEB in Grotton are both the largest employers in “company towns”. People who had jobs there stayed even though the pay was not great for highly skilled work.

Those cold war workers are either retired or retiring. Young workers aren’t interested in working on high skill low paid jobs where they won’t earn enough to buy a house. So they leave. Especially when highly skilled welders make far more in the oil and gas industry. The USN and RN both need to take a firmer line with GDEB and BAE, not practice corporate welfare. The alternative is to more highly automate the shipyards like Japan and Korea have done, but that takes real investment by BAE and GDEB.
https://www.usni.org/magazines/proceedings/2026/august/shipbuilding-train-them-pay-them-protect-them

Shawn C said...

Greetings all,

I call to your attention two recent articles published on UKdefensejournal.com:

Institute calls for the UK to keep two Astute-class submarine “fully-
deployable and operational at all times.” This is in light of the news that zero Astute class submarines were available over the summer 2026, when four were supposed to be ‘in-commission”. HMS Astute has been in maintenance since June 2025 for its Mid Life Re-Validation Period.
https://ukdefencejournal.org.uk/call-for-two-attack-submarines-at-sea-at-all-times/

During UK parliament Question Time, the Minister of State for Defence said “The major facility upgrades required to support Dreadnought reactor core production have been delivered, with activity now focused on completing final commissioning, manufacturing and delivering the reactor cores required.”

If Rolls-Royce is on track for Dreadnaught reactor core production, this also means that it’s currently also on track for SSN-AUKUS production, which uses the same PWR3. The RN is supposedly ordering twelve SSN, with Australia producing an RAN version in ASC.
https://ukdefencejournal.org.uk/reactor-core-plant-upgrades-for-dreadnought-delivered/

Shawn C said...

Hi Anonymous at 11/01/2026 8:13 AM

HMS Turbulent had a documentary video crew aboard during the first part of that 2011 patrol, where it suffered from a major issue with is toilets (sound familiar?). The boat then had crabs in its air con cooling pipes.

https://www.themoviedb.org/tv/93927-royal-navy-submarine-mission

Pete2 said...

Thanks Anonymous at 11/01/2026 8:13 AM

Yes https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2014/jun/04/nuclear-submarine-commander-recounts-how-disaster-was-narrowly-avoide did happen over 12 years ago.

SSNs, SSBNs and nuclear ships on occasion suffer from reactor coolant related sea life ingestion given the right/wrong conditions.

Cheers Pete

Pete2 said...

Hi Anonymous at 11/02/2026 7:44 PM

Please see my recent https://gentleseas.blogspot.com/2026/10/uk-rns-submarine-crisis-spreads.html which predated exactly what you said at in your first para at 11/02/2026 7:44 PM.

Thanks though for "This will limit the RN’s ability to train new SSN crew. The RN would appear to be in danger of losing its SSN ASW skills in future. Rebuilding them later may take many years." a fresh insight, which may well turn out to be true.

Cheers Pete

Pete2 said...

Thanks Anonymous at 11/02/2026 7:54PM

For https://www.usni.org/magazines/proceedings/2026/august/shipbuilding-train-them-pay-them-protect-them I've just republished this at https://gentleseas.blogspot.com/2026/11/labor-in-americas-shipbuilding-industry.html crediting Lt Gary Kim, the author.

Cheers Pete

Kev said...

As I have said before, I believe the AUS government should procure 6 taigei's instead of the collins LOTE. While there are some operational issues (aegis, range, armament) at maybe 6 billion aud for 6 taigei class submarines, it'll be the fiscally responsible and an 'off the shelf' solution that military planners have been calling for, for the past 2 decades. Unfortunately it stands as an option that policy makers won't make, even though they preach about fiscal responsibility and acquiring world class capability.

ASC which will construct ssn-aukus(es) is government owned so the issue isn't motivating the organisation but the employees within the firm to plan effectively and be productive. The Aus gov has more levers to pull compare to BAE, HI and GD-EB.

Pete2 said...

Greetings Shawn at 11/02/2026 11:48 PM

It would appear too many Pommy inmates of the Old Country have an under estimation of the effort needed to build new SSBN and SSN classes on a Secretary for Defence resigning stretched budget.

The PWR3, which will (or is) enjoying too many surprises of not being physically tested, only computer simulated, to save the UK's depleted defence budget, may go the way
of the PWR2 the RN enjoys today.

The Brits are cobbling a slightly smaller, reactor than PWR3 for Dreadnought called PWR3+ for SSN-AUKUS. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rolls-Royce_PWR#PWR3+

PommyGov have skated over the considerable cost, risk and delays of miniaturisation - something the French suffered when they took about 6 years to miniaturise the Triomphant class's larger K15 reactor into the smaller pressure hull of the Suffren/Barracuda class SSN.

Cheers Pete