Note that the new submarines will only begin to be built in about 12 years time - for entry into service not in the late 2020s but the early 2030s.
There is currently a political confrontation between former Prime Minister Abbott and current Prime Minister Turnbull over what Abbott perceives as a new submarine "delay".
Only beginning the build in 2027 may cause much uncertainty for the winning contender. The delay may effect TKMS and DCNS less as there is a full export or foreign build order book for TKMS (for Greece, Turkey, Egypt, Singapore, Israel and South Korea) and almost full for DCNS (India and Brazil).
For Japan it is a long wait. The delay may benefit Australia with the opportunity for Lithium-ion Batteries (LIBs), new diesels and the new snorkel system being operationally tested in Japanese Soryu Mark 2s and new, post Soryu class, over a longer period. If Japan is chosen see the Australian build details in red in the SORYU TABLE below.
If TKMS or DCNS are chosen Australia may benefit from those companies spending a longer period developing and testing new air independent propulsion (AIP) technologies and also LIBs.
Without the CEP contender even being announced the "delay" controversy should serve as a warning to contenders about how political the new submarine issue is in Australia. Australian government decisions may continue to be surprising, personality and election driven. Different Prime Ministers and Coalition versus Labor governments may have conflicting ideas as to when and where the submarines should be assembled.
SORYU TABLE (with earlier Oyashios, as
at March 22, 2016)
SS
No.
|
Build No
Name
|
Pennant
No.
|
MoF
approved amount ¥ Billions
& FY
|
LABs,
LIBs, AIP
|
Laid
Down
|
Laun
-ched
|
Commi-ssioned
|
Built
By
|
5SS
|
8105
Oyashio
|
SS-590/
TS3608
|
¥52.2B
FY1993
|
LABs
only
|
Jan
1994
|
Oct
1996
|
Mar
1998
|
KHI
|
6SS-15SS
Oyashios
10 subs
|
8106
-8115
various
|
SS-591-600
|
¥52.2B
per sub
FY1994-FY2003
|
LABs
only
|
Feb
1994
|
Mar
2008
|
MHI
&
KHI
|
|
16SS
Soryu
Mark 1
|
8116
Sōryū
|
SS-501
|
¥60B
FY2004
|
LABs +
AIP
|
Mar
2005
|
Dec
2007
|
Mar
2009
|
MHI
|
17SS
|
8117
Unryū
|
SS-502
|
¥58.7B
FY2005
|
LABs +
AIP
|
Mar
2006
|
Oct
2008
|
Mar
2010
|
KHI
|
18SS
|
8118
Hakuryū
|
SS-503
|
¥56.2
FY2006
|
LABs +
AIP
|
Feb
2007
|
Oct
2009
|
Mar
2011
|
MHI
|
19SS
|
8119
Kenryū
|
SS-504
|
¥53B FY2007
|
LABs +
AIP
|
Mar
2008
|
Nov
2010
|
Mar
2012
|
KHI
|
20SS
|
8120
Zuiryū
|
SS-505
|
¥51B
FY2008
|
LABs +
AIP
|
Mar
2009
|
Oct
2011
|
Mar
2013
|
MHI
|
No
21SS
|
No 21SS
built
|
|||||||
22SS
|
8121
Kokuryū
|
SS-506
|
¥52.8B
FY2010
|
LABs +
AIP
|
Jan
2011
|
Oct
2013
|
Mar
2015
|
KHI
|
23SS
|
8122
Jinryu
|
SS-507
|
¥54.6B
FY2011
|
LABs +
AIP
|
Feb
2012
|
Oct
2014
|
7 Mar
2016
|
MHI
|
24SS
|
8123
Sekiryū
|
SS-508
|
¥54.7B
FY2012
|
LABs +
AIP
|
Mar
2013
|
Nov
2015
|
Mar
2017
|
KHI
|
25SS
|
8124
|
SS-509
|
¥53.1B
FY2013
|
LABs +
AIP
|
Oct
2013
|
Nov
2016
|
Mar
2018
|
MHI
|
26SS
|
8125
|
SS-510
|
¥51.7B
FY2014
|
LABs +
AIP
|
?
|
?
|
Mar
2019
|
KHI
|
27SS
Soryu
Mark 2
|
8126
|
SS-511
|
¥64.3B
FY2015
|
LIBs
only
|
?
|
?
|
Mar
2020
|
MHI
|
28SS
|
8127
|
SS-512
|
¥63.6B
FY2016
|
LIBs
only
|
?
|
?
|
Mar
2021
|
KHI
|
29SS
|
?
|
?
|
1st of New
Japanese Class
|
LIBs
only
|
?
|
?
|
2023?
|
MHI?
|
Aus1
|
?
|
?
|
1st of new Aus class (if Japan chosen)
|
LIBs only
|
2028?
|
2030?
|
2033?
|
in Aus or Jpn?
|
Aus2 to 12?
|
?
|
?
|
between 5 and 11 additional Aus subs
|
LIBs only
|
from 2029?
|
from 2031?
|
from 2034?
|
in Aus or Jpn?
|
Table courtesy of information provided to Submarine
Matters. LABs = lead-acid batteries,
AIP = air independent
propulsion, LIBs = lithium-ion batteries.
Pete
Hi Pete
ReplyDeleteEverything consists of yin and yang. Such a haphazard planning has a merit. Leak of secret technology will delay a decade.
Regards
S
Hi S
ReplyDeleteYes there are so many ways for Russia and China to gather submarine design information through:
- systematic study of magazines and photos,
- buying diesels and AIP from European countries, and
- secret gathering by electronic-cyber and human (even "student") means.
Regards
Pete