The debate between advocates for Germany or Sweden, in the Netherlands future submarine competition, continues. The French contender has been strangely quiet...wonder why? Do the French know France has won, or what?
In the German corner Anonymous on February 5, 2021 commented :
"Dear Pete,
Magnetic signature is
an interesting topic. Germans always put a focus here because of the mine
threat in the Baltic Sea and the shallowness of it [see map below].
Lots of places and
opportunities there to hide from active sonar. Not so many to hide from
magnetometers . And magnetometers are likely to get
more powerful and so small that they even can be used from fairly small
unmanned aerial vehicles. (see this link eg: about “SQUID” sensors).
Smart design of the
submarine's degaussing system mitigates the problem to a
certain extent. However, this system continuously nibbles on your (limited)
amount of energy. Not so cool for the captain when his sub is in a high threat
environment. Best way to avoid a high magnetic signature is to dramatically
reduce the magnetic field of the steel structure. The rest can be reduced with
a much smaller degaussing system.
As always... it's some
kind of philosophical question and guessing what your future opponents
capabilities might be during the life cycle of your submarine."
_______________________________
Hi Pete, (corrected html)
ReplyDeleteSweden has been in Landsortsdjupet with its Submarine Rescue Vehicle the URF (Ubåtsräddningsfarkost) at 444 meter so they don't seem to have hit the deepest part or it's filled up with to much junk as it has been used to dump things even low graded radiactive waste it seems.
So it seems that all depths are covered at home waters.
As a detail it can be mention that the URF was being prepered to be sent to rescue the USS San Frisco's crew when it collided with underwater mountain, as it was deemed as being the fastest submarine rescue vehicle that could arrive at the scene, but it wasn't needed as the crew manage to stumble to Guam by themself.
Sorry all links are to Swedish text.
/Kjell
Thanks /Kjell
ReplyDeleteFor your Feb 9 comment on Sweden's submarine rescue vehicle.
Regards
Pete