March 18, 2024

Delayed Orkas? TKMS, Naval Group & Saab: Iranian "AIP"!

Shawn C, on Thursday March 14, 2024 (just before the Dutch Orka decision) commented offline:

TKMS MATTERS

https://youtu.be/hI5md1HOBT4?si=F0Qdw2SlPtG5RFrY

Note: TKMS just built a new sub building facility in Kiel. This will allow TKMS to simultaneously produce:

  • 2-3 submarines a year - not sure if he meant "build more subs"
  • Allows for the production of bigger boats – Type 212CD and 'bespoke customer requirements' (Which I thought was a hint at Israel's future Dakar class)
  • Planted questions about TKMS employment and supply to TKMS sales director.
  • Elaborated on 'orphan designs' - maybe based on Dolphin class experience? 
  • Production increase - can ramp up - speaks about Dutch production partner.
  • New TKMS hall improves production by 20% - to new submarine projects a year? RSS Invincible took 5 years to build (ordered 2013, construction began 2014, launched in 2019)
  • Uses Microsoft HoloLens for AR enhancement to production. https://www.microsoft.com/en-au/hololens 

Further on TKMS Production capacity:

NAVAL GROUP MATTERS

[Pete comment: Given the Netherlands has not finally chosen Naval Group’s (NG) Orka until the Dutch Parliament agrees...] Note: Between the three sub builders TKMS, NG and Saab. As a rough estimate, all three main shipbuilders (I have not assessed their Dutch partners) should have available construction facilities in 2027 for this program. 

All three are in active production of SSKs but NG is in India and Brazil.
[Pete comment: DCNS/NG last built Scorpenes in Cherboug up to 2009 along with 2 SSNs (in 2009) but not simultaneously with SSBNs. So Cherbourg production facilities (already for the remaining SSNs and future SSBNs) 
might be inadequate if Orkas also need to be built at Cherbourg? This might cause unexpected delays in the Orka Project. Will the Orkas need to be built elsewhere in France or in the Netherlands?] 
I do not think NG will want to divert French SNLE 3G/SSBN production
.

Suffren-class - the last in class NG Casabianca estimated 2029 delivery - 3 boats are concurrently in production, with the next two expected in 2025 and 2027. With the Rubis-class Saphir-Perle also returned to service in 2023, this may mean that NG has clear yard space (and clear Barracuda production facilities), though the SNLE 3G SSBN production was supposed to start at the end of 2023. [apparently the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SNLE_3G has not even been laid down yet!]

SAAB MATTERS

[Pete comment: As Saab has no foreign orders Saab’s loss of the Orka-class competition is a bitter blow. Saab may become involved in Australia's Collins Life of Type Extension (LOTE) from 2026 but that is not certain.]

Saab: 2 x A26 Blekinge-class are in production, with expected delivery in 2027 & 2028, last Gotland refit should be completed. [Maybe 2 more Blekinges will be ordered in the 2030s?].

SINGAPORE NAVY MATTERS

Wow! This is fast! 30 min before I saw this I was at the Singapore Ministry of Defense (Mindef) site checking press releases! 

https://www.navalnews.com/naval-news/2024/03/singapore-cuts-steel-on-its-first-multirole-combat-vessel-mrcv/

Not out yet on Singapore news sites.

8,000 ton Multi Role Combat Vessel (MRCV) frigate with a 4 year delivery date... very ambitious.
 

“HOT” IRANIAN AIP OFFER

Does anyone want to buy Iranian AIP [on a 600 tonne Fateh-class submarine] ?

https://www.navalnews.com/event-news/dimdex-2024/2024/03/iran-unveils-aip-version-of-fateh-class-submarine-at-dimdex-2024/

2 comments:

  1. Hi Pete,

    Unrelated to the topic, but regarding something we talked about before:

    India has officially announced its test of an improved Agni-5 ballistic missile with Multiple Independently Targetable Re-entry Vehicles (MIRVs) last week.

    https://fas.org/publication/indian-test-launch-of-mirv-missile-latest-sign-of-emerging-nuclear-arms-race/

    They did not release any information regarding how many re-entry vehicles this payload bus was tested with, but some defence journalists are speculating it wouldn't be bigger than a 3 or 4-MIRV configuration.

    It serves to note that at least two Chinese intelligence-gathering vessels were in the Indian Ocean Region during the period when the Notice to Airmen (NOTAM) for the test was in effect.

    One can't help but think back to the times when the Americans & the Soviets used to launch SLBM tests from their submarines when in positions where they can be assured that the other side gets a good look at your nuclear delivery capabilities - so that the purpose of deterrence is served.

    I wonder when the MIRVed K5 SLBM will show up.

    Cheers

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks Gessler at 3/19/2024 4:18 AM

    I'll turn your comments and link into an article later this week.

    Cheers Pete

    ReplyDelete

You can comment :)